Discernment counselling or mediation: what is the difference?
Discernment counselling and mediation answer different questions at different stages. Discernment counselling helps a couple who disagree about the future decide whether to try to save the relationship, separate, or keep things as they are for now. Family mediation helps a couple who have already decided to separate agree practical arrangements, such as for children and money, with an independent mediator. If a couple chooses separation at the end of discernment counselling, mediation may come next.
Two different questions
Discernment counselling and family mediation both involve a couple and a professional, and both often come up when divorce is being considered. They answer different questions.
- Discernment counselling asks: should we try to save this relationship, separate, or keep things as they are for now?
- Family mediation asks: now that we are separating, how will we arrange things for our children, our home and our money?
Discernment counselling comes before the decision. Mediation usually comes after it.
How they compare
| Discernment counselling | Family mediation | |
|---|---|---|
| The question | Whether to separate | How to separate |
| Who it is for | Couples where one partner is leaning out and the other wants to try | Couples who have decided to separate |
| What happens | Mostly separate conversations with each partner, then short shared summaries | Joint or separate meetings to negotiate arrangements |
| The professional's role | Helps each partner reach clarity and confidence about a direction | Helps the couple reach agreements they can both accept |
| Length | One to five sessions | Varies with what needs to be agreed |
| The outcome | A choice between three paths | Proposals or agreements about children, property and money |
| Legal advice | None | None, though a mediator can explain what is needed to make an agreement binding |
These are general descriptions. How mediation works, and its legal status, differs between countries.
What discernment counseling does
Discernment counselling was developed for "mixed-agenda" couples, where one partner is leaning towards divorce and the other wants to keep the relationship and work on it. Its goal is clarity and confidence about the next step, based on a deeper understanding of what has happened and of each partner's part in it.
It runs for a maximum of five sessions. Most of each session is spent in a separate conversation between the counsellor and each partner. At the end, the couple chooses one of three paths: stay as things are for now, move towards separation, or commit to six months of couples therapy with divorce off the table. The article on what discernment counselling is explains the process.
Discernment counselling does not negotiate anything. The counsellor does not help the couple divide property or agree arrangements for children, and does not give legal advice.
What family mediation does
Family mediation is for couples who are separating. As the Family Mediation Council in England and Wales describes it, an independent, professionally trained mediator helps a couple work out arrangements for children and finances, and explains what needs to happen to make an agreement legally binding. Nobody can be made to agree to anything against their wishes.
Mediation is not designed to decide whether a couple should separate, and it is not a form of couples therapy. The details, including whether mediation is expected before going to court, vary between countries. A family lawyer where you live can explain what applies.
Why they are sometimes confused
The two are easy to mix up for several reasons:
- Both involve the couple together. People often assume that any meeting with both partners and a neutral professional is mediation.
- Both are offered around divorce. Lawyers and mediators can be the first professionals a couple meets when one partner is thinking of leaving. Discernment counselling was developed with family lawyers for exactly that moment.
- Both aim to reduce conflict. Mediation is often used as an alternative to settling things through the courts. Discernment counselling helps a couple reach a decision with more understanding, which can affect how a separation goes if they choose one.
The difference is timing. If one partner is still unsure whether to separate, mediation is likely to be premature. If both have decided, discernment counselling is not the right process.
When each one fits
Discernment counselling may fit if:
- one partner is seriously considering leaving but has not finally decided
- the other partner wants to try to save the relationship
- both are willing to take part, at least for one session
Mediation may fit if:
- both partners have decided to separate
- you need to agree arrangements for children, property or money
- you would prefer to reach agreements together than have them decided for you
Neither may be right yet if either partner is afraid of the other, or there is violence, coercion or a court protection order. Discernment counselling is not suitable in those situations. If you are considering mediation, tell the mediator before it begins, and contact a domestic abuse service for support. The article on when discernment counselling is not appropriate explains why.
Questions to ask yourselves
If you are not sure which you need, these questions can help:
- Has either of us actually decided to separate? If one of you is still unsure, the question is whether, not how.
- Do we agree that the relationship is ending? Mediation works best when both partners accept the decision.
- Are we both willing to take part? Both processes need each partner to attend, at least at the start.
- Is either of us afraid of the other? If so, speak to a domestic abuse service before starting either process.
Moving from one to the other
The two can follow one another. The University of Minnesota's Couples on the Brink Project developed a short protocol for lawyers and mediators to use in first consultations, to recognise ambivalence about divorce and refer couples to discernment counselling. In the other direction, if a couple chooses separation at the end of discernment counselling, the counsellor helps steer them towards divorce professionals, who may include mediators.
The articles on discernment counselling for family lawyers and what happens after discernment counselling cover both directions in more detail.
This article is general information, not legal or financial advice.
Common questions
Is discernment counseling a form of mediation?
No. A mediator helps separating partners negotiate arrangements. A discernment counsellor helps a couple decide whether to separate at all, and does not negotiate arrangements for children, property or money.
Can a mediator refer us to discernment counselling?
Yes. The University of Minnesota's Couples on the Brink Project developed a short protocol for lawyers and mediators to use in first consultations, to recognise when a couple may not be ready to separate and to refer them to discernment counselling.
Do we need a lawyer as well as a mediator?
It depends on where you live and what you need to agree. This article is not legal advice. A family lawyer can explain how mediation works in your country and whether you also need independent legal advice.
Can discernment counselling help us agree arrangements for our children?
Not directly. If a couple chooses to separate, discernment counselling can help them agree how they want to treat each other, but arrangements for children are worked out with a mediator, lawyers or the courts.
Lucy Orton is trained in discernment counselling through the Doherty Relationship Institute and offers it internationally and online. She does not offer mediation or legal advice.
References
- Doherty Relationship Institute. Discernment Counseling. discernmentcounseling.com
- University of Minnesota, Department of Family Social Science. Minnesota Couples on the Brink Project: Lawyers and mediators. innovation.umn.edu
- University of Minnesota, Department of Family Social Science. Minnesota Couples on the Brink Project: Discernment counseling for couples. innovation.umn.edu
- Family Mediation Council. Family mediation. familymediationcouncil.org.uk
- Doherty, W. J., Harris, S. M., & Wilde, J. L. (2016). Discernment counseling for ‘mixed-agenda’ couples. Journal of Marital and Family Therapy, 42(2), 246-255. doi:10.1111/jmft.12132
If you feel unsafe with your partner or are afraid of them, couples work and discernment counselling are not the right starting point. Please contact a domestic abuse service or local emergency services.
This page is general information about intensive therapy. It is not a substitute for individual assessment or advice, and reading it does not create a therapeutic relationship. If you are in crisis or at risk of harm, contact local emergency services or a crisis line now. How these articles are written and checked: our editorial standards.