Learn · Discernment counselling

What happens after discernment counselling?

What happens after discernment counselling depends on the path the couple chooses. A couple who stays as they are for now carries on, usually with a time to revisit the decision. A couple who separates moves on to professionals such as mediators or lawyers, with a clearer understanding of what happened and an agreement about how to treat each other. A couple who chooses reconciliation begins six months of couples therapy, with divorce off the table and each partner working on their own changes.

Written by , MSc, PGDip, DipCouns, registered counsellor (ACA #27921), founder of The Centre for Intensives. Last reviewed .

The end of the process is a decision, not a fix

Discernment counselling ends when the couple has chosen a direction. It is not designed to repair the relationship during the sessions, so the real work, whichever way it goes, happens afterwards. The three choices are set out in the three paths graphic: stay as you are for now, move towards separation, or commit to six months of couples therapy.

What follows depends on the path. This article describes what each one usually looks like in practice.

When couples finish discernment counselling with me, what happens next depends on the path. Some come to me for path 3, and some return to an existing couples therapist for it. Those who choose path 1 and leave things as they are may have a maintenance session or two with me or another couples therapist, or decide to go without therapy. For those who decide to separate, individual therapy sometimes comes out of the decision-making process.

From Lucy’s practice

What happens after discernment counseling ends

Path What the couple decides What usually happens next
Stay as you are for now Keep the relationship as it is, without starting couples therapy yet Life carries on, ideally with a time agreed to revisit the decision
Move towards separation End the relationship The couple turns to professionals who support a constructive separation, such as mediators and lawyers
Six months of couples therapy Make a full effort at reconciliation, with divorce off the table Couples therapy begins, with each partner working on their own agenda for change

Path one: staying as you are for now

Choosing to stay as you are is not a failure, and it is not the same as giving up. Sometimes neither partner is ready to make a larger decision, or circumstances such as a new baby, an illness or a move make it the wrong moment. The University of Minnesota's description of the process notes that some couples take a time out and return to the decision later.

In practice, couples on this path often find it helps to:

  • agree when they will revisit the question, instead of leaving it open indefinitely
  • notice whether the patterns they identified during discernment counselling are changing
  • consider individual therapy for either partner, if something personal came to light

Path two: moving towards separation

On this path, the couple decides to end the relationship. Discernment counselling does not handle the separation itself, but it can shape how it happens. The University of Minnesota describes the counsellor helping partners find professionals who can help them have a constructive divorce, and its guidance for lawyers notes that the counsellor steers couples towards divorce professionals.

In practice this can mean:

  1. Agreeing how to treat each other. Couples who choose this path can use the final session to agree principles for how they will separate, especially where children are involved.
  2. Choosing the right professionals. Mediators help separating couples agree arrangements for children and money. Collaborative lawyers and family lawyers advise on the legal side. The article on discernment counselling or mediation explains the difference.
  3. Carrying the understanding forward. Each partner leaves with a clearer view of what happened and of their own part in it. That can make it easier to separate without each blaming the other for everything.

Research here is limited. In a small 2021 study of people who divorced after discernment counselling, participants described it as helping them reach clarity and honesty about the decision, and reported more cooperation as parents afterwards. The study involved 11 people and had no comparison group.

This article is not legal or financial advice. Questions about divorce, children, property and money belong with a family lawyer or financial adviser where you live. The article on whether to see a discernment counsellor or a lawyer first covers how the two fit together.

Path three: six months of couples therapy

The Doherty Relationship Institute describes this path as a six-month commitment to couples therapy, with a clear agenda for personal change and with divorce off the table during that time. Taking divorce off the table matters: it gives the partner who was leaning out a defined period in which to try, without having to promise a lifetime, and it gives the partner who was leaning in a fair chance to show that change is possible.

In practice:

  • Each partner has their own agenda. The focus is on what each person will change in themselves, not on what the other must change. Much of this agenda takes shape during discernment counselling.
  • The therapy needs a format. In the original description, this means six months of couples therapy. Some couples choose regular sessions, and some begin with a concentrated couples intensive followed by regular sessions. The article on discernment counselling and couples intensives explains why the two are kept separate and how a couple moves from one to the other.
  • The decision comes back at the end. After six months, the couple decides again, this time with the experience of having made a full effort.

Support for each of you

Whichever path a couple chooses, the weeks afterwards can feel unsettled. A decision that has been made does not always feel settled straight away. Some things that can help:

  • Keeping to what you agreed. Whether that is a date to revisit the decision, principles for separating, or a start date for couples therapy, following through builds trust.
  • Individual support. Either partner may want individual therapy for something that came to light during the process, whatever path they are on.
  • Thinking about children together. If you have children, it helps to agree what you will tell them, and when, before either of you says anything.

What the research shows about the paths

In the first published analysis of discernment counselling, 100 consecutive couples were analysed. About half chose to start couples therapy to try to reconcile, and most of the rest chose the divorce path. The paper also reported longer-term follow-up, but without a comparison group no conclusions can be drawn about whether discernment counselling changes how couples fare afterwards. What it offers is a structured way to reach the decision. What happens next depends on the couple, and on the help they choose.

Common questions

Is choosing to separate after discernment counseling a failure?

No. Discernment counselling treats separation as a legitimate outcome. Its aim is a well-made decision, reached with clarity and confidence, whichever path that is.

What happens at the end of the six months of couples therapy?

The couple decides again, this time with the experience of having made a full effort. They may commit to the relationship, or they may decide to separate, knowing that they tried.

Can we come back to discernment counselling later?

Sometimes. The University of Minnesota's description notes that some couples take a time out from the process and return to it later. Whether that is possible depends on the practitioner.

Does the discernment counsellor help with the divorce itself?

Not with the legal process. If a couple chooses to separate, the counsellor can help them think about how they want to treat each other and point them towards professionals who support a constructive separation. Legal and financial questions belong with a lawyer or financial adviser.

Lucy Orton is trained in discernment counselling through the Doherty Relationship Institute. If a couple chooses the six-month path, she offers couples therapy through Couples Awaken, starting with a couples intensive followed by fortnightly or monthly sessions.

Discernment counselling at Couples Awaken

References

  1. Doherty Relationship Institute. Discernment Counseling. discernmentcounseling.com
  2. University of Minnesota, Department of Family Social Science. Minnesota Couples on the Brink Project: Discernment counseling for couples. innovation.umn.edu
  3. University of Minnesota, Department of Family Social Science. Minnesota Couples on the Brink Project: Lawyers and mediators. innovation.umn.edu
  4. Doherty, W. J., Harris, S. M., & Wilde, J. L. (2016). Discernment counseling for ‘mixed-agenda’ couples. Journal of Marital and Family Therapy, 42(2), 246-255. doi:10.1111/jmft.12132
  5. Emerson, A. J., Harris, S. M., & Ahmed, F. A. (2021). The impact of discernment counseling on individuals who decide to divorce: Experiences of post-divorce communication and coparenting. Journal of Marital and Family Therapy, 47(1), 36-51. doi:10.1111/jmft.12463

If you feel unsafe with your partner or are afraid of them, couples work and discernment counselling are not the right starting point. Please contact a domestic abuse service or local emergency services.

This page is general information about intensive therapy. It is not a substitute for individual assessment or advice, and reading it does not create a therapeutic relationship. If you are in crisis or at risk of harm, contact local emergency services or a crisis line now. How these articles are written and checked: our editorial standards.