Learn · Discernment counselling

I'm the one leaning in. What can discernment counselling offer me?

Discernment counselling gives the partner who is leaning in a fair hearing and a constructive role at a frightening time. It will not persuade your partner to stay, and it does not ask you to give up hope. Instead, it helps you hear what your partner is saying about the relationship, respond without pushing them further away, and look honestly at your own part in the difficulties. That is useful whether the relationship continues or not.

Written by , MSc, PGDip, DipCouns, registered counsellor (ACA #27921), founder of The Centre for Intensives. Last reviewed .

Where you are starting from

If you are the partner who is leaning in, you want the relationship to continue, and your partner is seriously thinking about leaving. The Doherty Relationship Institute calls this the "leaning-in" position: you are interested in couples therapy, and your partner is not sure it is worth trying.

This is often a frightening place to be. You may have been shocked by how far your partner has moved away, or you may have felt it coming for a long time. You may feel desperate to do something, and powerless at the same time. Discernment counselling was designed for couples in exactly this situation, and it has a clear role for you. The article on who discernment counselling is for describes the fit in more detail.

Partners who are leaning in often feel very vulnerable. They are trying to champion the marriage at a time when they feel low and worried. They may desperately not want it to end, while also having to hold back from pushing too hard on their partner who is leaning out. There are moments when they feel less confident in their leaning in, and yet they are the one most confident in the relationship. It is a hard balance to keep.

From Lucy’s practice

Why discernment counseling is different from couples therapy for you

Couples therapy usually assumes that both partners want to improve the relationship. When one partner does not, the partner who is leaning in can end up doing most of the pushing, and the partner who is leaning out can end up resisting it. Therapy stalls, and the decision is never really made.

Discernment counselling does not ask your partner to commit to repair. That can feel like a disappointment at first. But it gives your partner room to think honestly, instead of attending under pressure, and that is what makes a real decision possible. If your partner does choose to try, the decision will be one they have made for themselves.

What you can expect

A fair hearing

The counsellor works with both of you and respects each person's position. Wanting to stay is not treated as naive, and wanting to leave is not treated as wrong. The University of Minnesota describes the counsellor working to understand both partners, even when they see things very differently.

Private time of your own

Most of each session is spent in separate conversations. In your individual time, you can say how frightened, angry or hurt you are without managing your partner's reaction. The article on what happens in discernment counselling sessions explains how the time is divided and how confidentiality works.

A constructive role

In the published description of the method, the work with the partner who is leaning in focuses on three things:

  1. Hearing what your partner is saying about the relationship, including things that are painful to hear.
  2. Responding constructively under pressure, at one of the most stressful times of your life.
  3. Using the crisis to look at your own part in the difficulties, and at what you could change.

What tends to help, and what tends to harm

When a relationship feels as if it is slipping away, it is natural to try harder. The counsellor helps you notice when trying harder turns into patterns that tend to push a doubtful partner further away, such as pursuing, pleading or scolding.

Discernment counselling does not give you a script, and it cannot make your partner stay. What it offers is help to stay steady: to say what you feel without pressing for an answer, and to show through how you respond, not only through promises, that you are taking the difficulties seriously. That gives the relationship a fair chance, and it means that whatever happens, you have acted in a way you can respect.

Looking after yourself during the process

Discernment counselling is short, but the weeks it covers can be some of the hardest of your life. You may be sleeping badly, struggling to concentrate at work, or replaying conversations late at night. It helps to have support that does not depend on your partner.

  • Someone to talk to. A trusted friend, a family member who will not take sides, or an individual therapist can give you somewhere to put what you feel between sessions.
  • Some steadiness in daily life. Keeping to ordinary routines, eating and resting where you can, makes it easier to respond calmly when it matters.
  • Questions for your individual time. It can help to note down what you want to say or ask in your next session, so that the time is used for what matters most to you.

Looking at your own part

This can be the hardest part of the process for the partner who is leaning in. When your partner wants to leave, it can feel as if the problem is theirs. Discernment counselling asks each partner to look at their own contribution, because the pattern between two people is made by both.

That is not about blame. It is about understanding. Doherty's team sums up one of the central ideas this way: you cannot divorce yourself. What you learn about your own part goes with you into the relationship if it continues, and into your future if it does not.

How it ends for you

At the end of discernment counselling, the couple chooses between three paths: stay as things are for now, move towards separation, or commit to six months of couples therapy with divorce off the table. In the first published analysis of 100 couples, about half chose couples therapy, and most of the rest chose divorce.

If your partner chooses to leave, discernment counselling treats that as a legitimate outcome, not a failure on your part. In a small study of people who divorced after discernment counselling, participants described more clarity about the decision and more cooperation as parents afterwards. The article for the other partner, what discernment counselling offers the partner who is leaning out, shows the process from their side.

Common questions

Can discernment counseling save my marriage?

It is not designed to. Its aim is a well-made decision about the relationship, not repair. If you both choose to try reconciliation at the end, the repair work happens in couples therapy afterwards. About half of the couples in the first published analysis chose that path.

Should I tell my partner how much I want to stay?

It is natural to want to. Discernment counselling helps you express what you feel in a way your partner can hear, without pleading or pressing them for an answer, which tends to push a doubtful partner further away.

What if my partner chooses to leave anyway?

That is possible, and it is painful. Discernment counselling treats separation as a legitimate outcome. What you have learned about yourself and the relationship stays with you, and it can help you separate with more understanding and less blame.

Will the counsellor take my side because I want to save the relationship?

No. The counsellor works with both of you and respects each person's position. Wanting to stay is not treated as more right than wanting to leave.

In discernment counselling with Lucy Orton, each partner has private time to speak honestly. Nobody will tell you to let go, and nobody will promise you an outcome.

Discernment counselling at Couples Awaken

References

  1. Doherty, W. J., Harris, S. M., & Wilde, J. L. (2016). Discernment counseling for ‘mixed-agenda’ couples. Journal of Marital and Family Therapy, 42(2), 246-255. doi:10.1111/jmft.12132
  2. Doherty Relationship Institute. Discernment Counseling. discernmentcounseling.com
  3. University of Minnesota, Department of Family Social Science. Minnesota Couples on the Brink Project: Discernment counseling for couples. innovation.umn.edu
  4. Emerson, A. J., Harris, S. M., & Ahmed, F. A. (2021). The impact of discernment counseling on individuals who decide to divorce: Experiences of post-divorce communication and coparenting. Journal of Marital and Family Therapy, 47(1), 36-51. doi:10.1111/jmft.12463

If you feel unsafe with your partner or are afraid of them, couples work and discernment counselling are not the right starting point. Please contact a domestic abuse service or local emergency services.

This page is general information about intensive therapy. It is not a substitute for individual assessment or advice, and reading it does not create a therapeutic relationship. If you are in crisis or at risk of harm, contact local emergency services or a crisis line now. How these articles are written and checked: our editorial standards.